Jump to content
Touring Motor Gliders Association (TMGA)

Nose Plate AD AMOC approved and deadline extended


Recommended Posts

Posted

All G109 and G109B owners,

The AMOC for the Noseplate Inspection has been approved. The basic points are a smaller hole, 16 mm, and an inspection camera may be substituted for the original 110 mm hole and mirror and a 90 day time extension is provided, moving the compliance date to April 9th, 2013.

The “meat and tatties†part of the AMOC is below. Read it to see pertinent (but not all) details contained.

------------------------------------------------------------------

2.All provisions of AD 20 12-10-1 1 that are not specifically referenced above remain fully applicable and must be complied with accordingly. As justification for allowing this alternative inspection method, you state that you accomplished an inspection of a model 0 109B using both a mirror as specified in the AD and a flexible, inspection camera. You conclude that the flexible, inspection camera provides a better examination than the mirror in this particular application due to limitations imposed by the geometry of the 110 mm opening relative to the position of the nose plate when using a mirror. In addition, for operators that do not currently have an access hole, you provide the costs associated with installing this opening including parts, labor, and transportation costs to get the sailplane to an approved shop where the work can be performed.

As justification for extending the compliance due date by an additional three months, you state that no corrosion was found following the inspection on your glider, registration number N1O9BR, according to paragraph (f)(1)(i) of AD 2012-10-il. This inspection, which was accomplished prior to the original compliance deadline of October 09, 2012, was done to the top, front and rear sides of the vertical stabilizer nose plate, following Part A of the Accomplishment Instructions in Grob Aircraft S/B No. MSB8I7-58.

The FAA has reviewed your Global AMOC request and the substantiation that you have provided. Since our office is responsible to coordinate such proposals with the state of design authority and the type certificate (TC) holder, we shared this request by e-mail with the European Aviation Safety Agency (EASA), and with Grob Aircraft AG. The EASA Project Certification Manager for Grob Aircraft kindly provided a quick response due to the urgent nature of this request. Based on his discussions with Grob Aircraft, he stated that neither he nor Grob Aircraft had any objections to the use of the alternative inspection method you have proposed. He also stated that Grob Aircraft had tried a similar inspection method and found it acceptable for addressing the unsafe condition.

After further consideration within the Small Airplane Directorate, the FAA agrees with your request to use an alternative inspection method, as defined in Attachment i, to accomplish the requirements of paragraphs (f)(l)(ii) and (0(1 )(iii) of AD 2012-10-1 i. After initial accomplishment, this alternative inspection method will need to be repeated at intervals not to exceed 12 months as specified in paragraph (f)(l)(iii). The FAA also agrees to extend the compliance due date to April 09, 2013 for paragraphs (f)(l)(ii) and (0(1 )(iii) of the AD, provided that the operator has previously completed the inspection from paragraph (f)(i)(i) with no adverse findings.

Before using this AMOC, operators are to notify their appropriate principal inspector, or lacking a principal inspector, the manager of the local flight standards district office/certificate holding district office. This approval is subject to the following conditions:

1. The Small Airplane Directorate will revoke this AMOC, if we later determine that this AMOC does not provide an acceptable level of safety.

Posted

All G109 and G109B owners,

The AMOC for the Noseplate Inspection has been approved. The basic points are a smaller hole, 16 mm, and an inspection camera may be substituted for the original 110 mm hole and mirror and a 90 day time extension is provided, moving the compliance date to April 9th, 2013.

The “meat and tatties†part of the AMOC is below. Read it to see pertinent (but not all) details contained.

------------------------------------------------------------------

2.All provisions of AD 20 12-10-1 1 that are not specifically referenced above remain fully applicable and must be complied with accordingly. As justification for allowing this alternative inspection method, you state that you accomplished an inspection of a model 0 109B using both a mirror as specified in the AD and a flexible, inspection camera. You conclude that the flexible, inspection camera provides a better examination than the mirror in this particular application due to limitations imposed by the geometry of the 110 mm opening relative to the position of the nose plate when using a mirror. In addition, for operators that do not currently have an access hole, you provide the costs associated with installing this opening including parts, labor, and transportation costs to get the sailplane to an approved shop where the work can be performed.

As justification for extending the compliance due date by an additional three months, you state that no corrosion was found following the inspection on your glider, registration number N1O9BR, according to paragraph (f)(1)(i) of AD 2012-10-il. This inspection, which was accomplished prior to the original compliance deadline of October 09, 2012, was done to the top, front and rear sides of the vertical stabilizer nose plate, following Part A of the Accomplishment Instructions in Grob Aircraft S/B No. MSB8I7-58.

The FAA has reviewed your Global AMOC request and the substantiation that you have provided. Since our office is responsible to coordinate such proposals with the state of design authority and the type certificate (TC) holder, we shared this request by e-mail with the European Aviation Safety Agency (EASA), and with Grob Aircraft AG. The EASA Project Certification Manager for Grob Aircraft kindly provided a quick response due to the urgent nature of this request. Based on his discussions with Grob Aircraft, he stated that neither he nor Grob Aircraft had any objections to the use of the alternative inspection method you have proposed. He also stated that Grob Aircraft had tried a similar inspection method and found it acceptable for addressing the unsafe condition.

After further consideration within the Small Airplane Directorate, the FAA agrees with your request to use an alternative inspection method, as defined in Attachment i, to accomplish the requirements of paragraphs (f)(l)(ii) and (0(1 )(iii) of AD 2012-10-1 i. After initial accomplishment, this alternative inspection method will need to be repeated at intervals not to exceed 12 months as specified in paragraph (f)(l)(iii). The FAA also agrees to extend the compliance due date to April 09, 2013 for paragraphs (f)(l)(ii) and (0(1 )(iii) of the AD, provided that the operator has previously completed the inspection from paragraph (f)(i)(i) with no adverse findings.

Before using this AMOC, operators are to notify their appropriate principal inspector, or lacking a principal inspector, the manager of the local flight standards district office/certificate holding district office. This approval is subject to the following conditions:

1. The Small Airplane Directorate will revoke this AMOC, if we later determine that this AMOC does not provide an acceptable level of safety.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

An AMOC has been developed here in Australia as well. I had already bought the kit for the inspection hole so I have installed that.

The plate on my 109 is completely covered with a bulge of flox and layers of glass. I cannot see the plate even with the big hole!!!

There is no evidence of corrosion on the plate above the rib so I'm thinking that the whole thing was a total waste of time and money!

Ray Tolhurst

VH-ZAK

Camden Airport

Australia

Posted

An AMOC has been developed here in Australia as well. I had already bought the kit for the inspection hole so I have installed that.

The plate on my 109 is completely covered with a bulge of flox and layers of glass. I cannot see the plate even with the big hole!!!

There is no evidence of corrosion on the plate above the rib so I'm thinking that the whole thing was a total waste of time and money!

Ray Tolhurst

VH-ZAK

Camden Airport

Australia

Posted

Several of us owners agreed that if no corrosion was obvious on the exposed Nose Plate that it was unlikely it would exist below the horizontal bulkhead. Furthermore, it appears that all B models are encased totally. Apparently, even some 109's are totally wrapped. The FAA was unable to get Grob or EASA to budge on at least "attempting" to inspect below the horizontal bulkhead and therefore could not, in turn, provide US owners with any relief on the inspection requirement. They (Grob and EASA) think corrosion will be visible as an obvious discoloration beneath the fiberglass. I just looked at my 109B this morning and it looks "good".

Stu

Posted

Several of us owners agreed that if no corrosion was obvious on the exposed Nose Plate that it was unlikely it would exist below the horizontal bulkhead. Furthermore, it appears that all B models are encased totally. Apparently, even some 109's are totally wrapped. The FAA was unable to get Grob or EASA to budge on at least "attempting" to inspect below the horizontal bulkhead and therefore could not, in turn, provide US owners with any relief on the inspection requirement. They (Grob and EASA) think corrosion will be visible as an obvious discoloration beneath the fiberglass. I just looked at my 109B this morning and it looks "good".

Stu

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...